ClairaClaira Help Desk
AI ReviewPromptingTemplatesRelevance

Identify Key Documents

Other languages

Identify Key Documents

Use this template to find the documents a lawyer will want in front of them when preparing the case, and to record why each one matters.

ClairaPrompt LabQuickstartPrompt LibraryKey documentsIdentify Key Documents

Insert Template puts this prompt into the prompt box. Claira writes each answer to the destination field you choose: a Memo field, for example the Key documents field that Getting started offers.

Key documentsMemoclaira-key-documents-01

What this prompt is for

This template codes each document KEYDOC or NOTKEY and gives every key document what it shows, the party it helps and the passage that matters most, quoted exactly. A reviewer can confirm each call without rereading the document, and every answer also carries a short description of the document.

A relevance pass tells you which documents belong in the review; it does not tell you which of them a lawyer will want in front of them. This template asks that second question of each document: does it directly prove or undermine a fact in dispute, show what someone knew or intended, record a decision, a commitment or an admission, or contradict another account? A document with no readable text, or one Claira cannot decide, is coded NOTKEY with the reason on the BASIS line.

Run it on the documents your relevance pass kept, then generate the Key documents Insight from the results. Do not run it on a whole collection: on documents that are not relevant it only answers NOTKEY. To code relevance itself, use Assess Relevance.

Step-by-step in Claira

  1. In Prompt Lab, click Quickstart above the prompt box. Bulk Scan has the same button.
  2. Under Prompt Library, open Key documents. On the Identify Key Documents card, click Expand to read the prompt, then click Insert Template. To have Claira fill in the case description from an approved Case Context, click Use with context instead.
  3. If the prompt box already has text, Replace existing prompt? asks what to do with it. Replace keeps the prompt tied to this template, which the finished bulk scan task needs to offer the Key documents Insight. Append adds the template below your text.
  4. If you used Insert Template, go to the prompt box and replace [insert case description: the parties, each side's position and the facts in dispute, one per line] with exactly that. Name each party the way you want the HELPS line to write it. Nothing flags a placeholder left in, so check it before you scan.
  5. Open a document in Nuix Discover and click Scan document. The answer appears under AI Response. To save it, choose the field in Apply to field... and click Apply. Do this on 10 to 25 documents that include documents you already consider key, and check that Claira marks them. Single scans are free.
  6. Select the documents your relevance pass marked relevant and click Start bulk scan. In Ready to start bulk scan, check the Destination field, then click Start bulk scan. When the task finishes, it offers the Key documents Insight.

The prompt

Decide whether this document is a key document for the following case:
[insert case description: the parties, each side's position and the facts in dispute, one per line]

A key document is one a lawyer would want in front of them when preparing the case. It directly proves or undermines a fact in dispute, shows what a person knew or intended and when, records a decision, a commitment or an admission, or contradicts another account of events. A document is not a key document when it is only relevant, routine or a copy of another document, or when it mentions a fact in dispute without evidencing it.

Match people and organizations under every name they appear as: full names, short names, initials, titles, roles, email addresses, acronyms and spelling variants.

If the document has no readable text or too little to judge, or you cannot decide, answer NOTKEY and give the reason on the BASIS line.

Answer in exactly this form, leaving out HELPS and PASSAGE for NOTKEY:
KEYDOC or NOTKEY
BASIS: for KEYDOC, what the document shows and the fact in dispute it bears on, in one or two sentences; for NOTKEY, why it is not a key document, in one sentence
HELPS: the party it helps, named as in the case description, or BOTH
PASSAGE: the sentence or short passage that matters most, quoted exactly between quotation marks
DESCRIPTION: one or two self-contained sentences naming the parties, the date and what the document is and concerns, for every document whatever the answer
  • Name the facts in dispute one by one. "Whether the March delivery was late" finds key documents; "the contract dispute" finds relevant ones.
  • Say what your side needs to prove and what the other side will argue, so the HELPS line can tell them apart.
  • Add the kinds of document your team already treats as key, for example signed minutes or a regulator's letter, to the definition.
  • Keep KEYDOC and NOTKEY as written. They are what you search for in Nuix Discover and what the Key documents Insight reads.

Worked example

With a case description in which Harbor Foods says its supplier, Northwind Supply, hid that the March 10 delivery would be late, and Northwind Supply says it gave notice as soon as it knew:

Input excerpt

Email dated 2025-03-04 from Northwind Supply's operations manager to its sales lead: "We will not make the March 10 delivery. Do not tell the customer until we have a new date."

Expected output shape

KEYDOC
BASIS: Northwind Supply knew on 4 March 2025 that it would miss the March 10 delivery and chose not to tell the customer, which undermines its account that it gave notice as soon as it knew.
HELPS: Harbor Foods
PASSAGE: "We will not make the March 10 delivery. Do not tell the customer until we have a new date."
DESCRIPTION: Email of 4 March 2025 from Northwind Supply's operations manager to its sales lead saying that the March 10 delivery will be missed and that the customer should not be told until there is a new date.

Troubleshooting

  • Most documents come back KEYDOC. The case description is too general. List the facts in dispute one per line and rerun the sample.
  • A document you consider key comes back NOTKEY. Read its BASIS line: it usually names the fact the case description left out.
  • PASSAGE paraphrases instead of quoting. Add "copied word for word from the document" to the PASSAGE line of the prompt. Claira does not compare a quoted passage with the document's text, so check a quotation against the document before you rely on it.
  • HELPS names the same party in different ways. Name each party once in the case description, the way you want it written, and say which side each is on.

Was this page helpful?

Need more help?

Contact our support team at support@claira.to — we are here to help.

On this page